Key Highlights
- Every SMSF must be audited each year, and for most trustees the audit ends with a signed report and little else.
- On 18 November 2026, two figures from the Auditors Institute raised the issue during a webinar the previous day.
- According to the ATO, an approved SMSF auditor must lodge an ACR within 28 days of completing the audit if, in the normal course of the audit, they form the opinion that a contravention.
- The ATO says auditors must tell trustees in writing if they believe a contravention has occurred, is occurring or may occur, and must advise whether the fund's financial position may be about to become.
Every SMSF must be audited each year, and for most trustees the audit ends with a signed report and little else. When an auditor identifies a breach that meets the ATO's reporting criteria, however, the fund's details go to the regulator in an auditor contravention report (ACR). That report can shape how the ATO views the fund and its trustees.
This week SMSF auditors called for more feedback from the ATO on what happens after those reports are lodged. The discussion is a useful prompt for trustees to understand when an ACR is triggered and what they can do to avoid one.
What auditors are asking for
On 18 November 2026, two figures from the Auditors Institute raised the issue during a webinar the previous day. Director David Burrows, managing director of Assurify, said he had reviewed submissions to the Australian National Audit Office's performance audit of the ATO's regulation of SMSFs. He said many raised concerns about the lack of information returned to practitioners who flagged issues in an ACR.
Burrows said submissions also described an "overly prescriptive approach", and suggested that purely administrative breaches that do not threaten a fund's tax concessions could distract from more serious integrity risks. He argued that better feedback would help the ATO target its compliance work.
Auditors Institute ambassador Graeme Colley said similar circumstances had at times produced quite different penalties for different funds without obvious explanation, and that practical examples of ATO decision-making would help. Auditors have asked for access to redacted ACRs and feedback on their own reports. These are industry views, not ATO policy.
When an auditor must lodge an ACR
According to the ATO, an approved SMSF auditor must lodge an ACR within 28 days of completing the audit if, in the normal course of the audit, they form the opinion that a contravention of the SIS Act or SIS Regulations may have occurred, may be occurring or may occur, and the contravention meets the reporting criteria.
The ATO's ACR instructions set out seven tests. In summary, a contravention is generally reportable if:
- the fund fails the SMSF definition, or a disqualified person is acting as Trustee or director
- the fund is less than 15 months old and any single contravention exceeds $2,000
- trustees were previously told about a breach of the same provision and breached it again
- a contravention from an earlier year has not been rectified by the current audit
- a statutory time limit was missed by more than 14 days
- the total value of contraventions exceeds 5 per cent of the fund's total assets; or
- contraventions of a listed provision total more than $30,000.
Auditors can also report matters below these thresholds if they believe the regulator should know, and they face a penalty of 50 penalty units if they Fail to lodge a required ACR.
What trustees are told
The ATO says auditors must tell trustees in writing if they believe a contravention has occurred, is occurring or may occur, and must advise whether the fund's financial position may be about to become unsatisfactory. This is often done through a management letter.
The ATO describes this early notice as an opportunity for trustees to fix, or plan to fix, issues before the audit is finalised. Trustees are also required to provide information the auditor requests within 14 days of a written request. Once an ACR is lodged, the ATO reviews it alongside other information it holds to decide what further action, if any, to take.
Practical considerations for trustees
Several of the reporting tests turn on trustee behaviour rather than dollar amounts. A repeated breach of the same rule, or a breach left unrectified from a previous year, can be reportable however small it is.
Hypothetical example: An SMSF auditor tells the trustees in a management letter that a $3,000 Loan from the fund to a member breached the lending rules. The amount is repaid within weeks. The next year, the trustees again lend a member $1,500 from the fund. Although both amounts are well below the $30,000 and 5 per cent thresholds, the second breach of the same provision after prior notice is likely to meet the reporting criteria.
Trustees may wish to:
- read management letters closely and act on them promptly
- keep evidence of rectification, such as bank records showing repayment
- respond to auditor requests within the 14-day timeframe
- consider the ATO's SMSF voluntary disclosure service for unrectified contraventions they identify themselves, before the auditor or ATO raises them.
Key Takeaways
ACRs are the main channel through which audit findings reach the ATO, and the reporting criteria focus as much on repeated or unrectified breaches as on large ones. Auditors are pushing for more transparency about how the regulator uses their reports, but whatever the outcome of that debate, trustees control the most important factor: avoiding breaches in the first place and fixing promptly any that occur.






Please wait processing your request...