Key Highlights
- Most SMSF trustees will only deal with the ATO occasionally: a lodgment question, a letter about the annual return, or a query raised after an audit.
- On 18 November 2026, Phil Broderick, Business law principal at Sladen Legal, urged the ATO to be more pragmatic in its role as SMSF regulator.
- The ATO's Investment requirements page states that SMSF investments must be made on a "commercial arm's length basis" and should reflect true market value.
- If market rates sat around 5 to 6 per cent, he said, a Loan at 4 or 8 per cent might once have been accepted as commercial.
Most SMSF trustees will only deal with the ATO occasionally: a lodgment question, a letter about the annual return, or a query raised after an audit. When those moments come, how the regulator approaches the conversation matters, and one experienced Superannuation lawyer says that approach has become noticeably less flexible.
Understanding why that view is being expressed, and what the ATO itself says trustees must be able to show, can help trustees prepare before a question is ever asked.
What was said
On 18 November 2026, Phil Broderick, business law principal at Sladen Legal, urged the ATO to be more pragmatic in its role as SMSF regulator. Speaking at The Tax Institute's National Superannuation Conference in Melbourne, he said the ATO's practicality in assessing SMSF compliance had narrowed in recent years.
Broderick recalled that, more than a decade ago, reasonable conversations with the ATO tended to produce reasonable outcomes. He said the regulator now appears to expect taxpayers to prove a transaction was at arm's length with something close to court-level evidence, whereas previously a deal that looked commercially sensible was generally accepted. He also said the ATO had been harsher with auditors, pursuing marginal breaches, and argued it should focus on practitioners doing seriously wrong things.
These are one practitioner's observations, not a statement of ATO policy, and the ATO has not changed the law. They do, however, highlight where trustees may face the most questions.
The arm's length rule itself
The legal requirement has not moved. The ATO's investment requirements page states that SMSF investments must be made on a "commercial arm's length basis" and should reflect true market value. It also sets out the sole purpose test: investments must be made and held to provide retirement benefits for members, or death benefits if a member dies before retirement.
The ATO warns that investments failing the sole purpose test can cost the fund its tax concessions and expose trustees to compliance action, including penalties. Where a transaction involves a related party, the practical question is often not whether the terms were reasonable, but whether the Trustee can demonstrate it.
Why evidence carries more weight
Broderick illustrated his point with interest rates. If market rates sat around 5 to 6 per cent, he said, a loan at 4 or 8 per cent might once have been accepted as commercial. Now, he suggested, the ATO would more likely expect evidence such as engagement with lenders to show the rate was commercial.
Hypothetical example: An SMSF borrows under a limited recourse borrowing arrangement from a family company to buy listed shares. Before signing, the trustee obtains written indicative terms from two commercial lenders for a comparable Facility and files them with a minute explaining how the agreed rate, term and security compare. If the ATO or auditor later asks whether the loan was on arm's length terms, the trustee can produce contemporaneous evidence rather than reconstructing the reasoning years later.
The same principle extends to most dealings with related parties: valuations, quotes and written agreements prepared at the time are far more persuasive than explanations offered after a query arrives.
Ways to engage the ATO
The ATO offers several channels that trustees can use before a problem arises:
- Self-help and general advice. The ATO suggests checking its published guidance first, then requesting general advice. Its SMSF phone line is 13 10 20, 8.00 am to 6.00 pm, Monday to Friday.
- SMSF specific advice. This is a written ATO view on how super law applies to a particular transaction, covering areas such as investment rules, related-party acquisitions, borrowing and benefit payments. It is not legally binding, but the ATO says that if trustees apply it, the ATO must administer the law accordingly unless the advice is wrong. It requires full and true disclosure of the facts.
- Voluntary disclosure. Trustees and their advisers can use the SMSF voluntary disclosure service to raise unrectified contraventions early.
The ATO notes that it cannot give financial or investment advice, so these channels are about how the law applies, not whether an investment is sensible.
Practical considerations for trustees
Trustees may wish to:
- document the commercial basis for any related-party transaction when it is entered into
- keep independent valuations, quotes and signed agreements with the fund's records
- record trustee decisions in minutes that explain the reasoning
- seek SMSF specific advice for novel or borderline arrangements before proceeding
- engage early through voluntary disclosure if a breach is discovered.
Key Takeaways
Whether or not the ATO has become less pragmatic, the arm's length and sole purpose requirements are long-standing, and the burden of showing compliance sits with trustees. Building evidence at the time a transaction is made, and using the ATO's advice channels before acting on uncertain arrangements, puts trustees in a stronger position if questions are later asked. Complex related-party arrangements may Warrant advice from a licensed adviser or superannuation lawyer.






Please wait processing your request...