Key Highlights

  • The support Options it listed were more time to pay, payment plans, remission, and referrals to support services.
  • The ATO's Debt book is over $60 billion, and the agency receives more than 100,000 remission requests a year through its penalty and interest hub.
  • At 100,000 requests a year, that is roughly 1,900 a week, or close to 385 every Business day across a 260-day working year.
  • The $60 billion-plus figure is the ATO's own current description of its debt book.

Responding to accountants raising concerns about support for taxpayers with outstanding debts, an ATO spokesperson acknowledged "feedback about consistency and transparency", with a debt book above $60 billion and more than 100,000 remission requests landing each year.

What the ATO said

The spokesperson went further, adding: "We acknowledge feedback about consistency and transparency in relation to our support."

The agency also addressed differing outcomes: "This means apparently similar cases may not result in the same outcome."

The ATO said it is changing its processes to make it clearer when remission is likely to be granted and to give clear reasons for decisions. It also said it is improving how it recognises vulnerability.

The support options it listed were more time to pay, payment plans, remission, and referrals to support services.

The scale: $60 billion and 100,000 requests

Two figures from the ATO's response frame the problem. The ATO's debt book is over $60 billion, and the agency receives more than 100,000 remission requests a year through its penalty and interest hub.

That Volume helps explain why decisions can vary. At 100,000 requests a year, that is roughly 1,900 a week, or close to 385 every business day across a 260-day working year. Each request turns on its own facts, such as the taxpayer's history, circumstances and reasons for falling behind.

The $60 billion-plus figure is the ATO's own current description of its debt book. It should not be confused with other published measures of tax debt, such as the $53.7 billion figure for 2025 cited by the Tax Ombudsman in a separate parliamentary submission. The two figures appear to be on different bases or dates.

Why accountants are pushing back

The ATO's comments followed criticism from practitioners.

"I think the ATO has lost sight of the fact that they're dealing with people. They're inconsistent," she said. She also said clients are "terrified of the ATO".

Accountant Miriam Bailey of AMD Chartered Accountants had sought penalty remission for a low-income client with significant mental-health issues. After the original story ran, the ATO contacted her about the client.

How remission and payment plans fit together

Remission is the ATO's discretion to reduce or cancel penalties or interest. It does not normally remove the underlying tax owed. Payment plans, by contrast, spread the debt out over time but do not, on their own, reduce it.

Because remission is discretionary, the ATO weighs each case individually. That is the context for its acknowledgement that "apparently similar cases" may end differently. Two taxpayers with similar debts may have different compliance histories, different reasons for late payment, or different evidence of hardship.

The ATO's stated reforms go to the two things practitioners say they want most: predictability (knowing when remission is likely) and reasons (understanding why a request was refused).

Hypothetical example: Suppose a sole trader owes $8,000 in primary tax plus $1,200 in penalties and interest, a total of $9,200. If the ATO remits half of the $1,200, the debt falls by $600 to $8,600. If the taxpayer then enters a 12-month payment plan, the instalments would be about $716.67 a month ($8,600 ÷ 12), before any further interest that may accrue on the outstanding balance. If remission were refused, the same 12-month plan would cost about $766.67 a month ($9,200 ÷ 12). The figures are illustrative only and do not reflect any actual ATO decision.

What this means for taxpayers with debts

The ATO's statement is news, not a change in law. There is no new legislation or formal ATO guidance yet setting out when remission will be granted. The ATO has said it is working on clearer processes, but it has not published the detail.

For people already in debt, the practical message from the ATO's own list is that several pathways exist: more time to pay, payment plans, remission requests and referrals to support services. The Bailey case, involving a low-income client with significant mental-health issues, shows the kind of personal circumstances the ATO says it is trying to recognise better when it considers vulnerability.

The issue also sits within a wider debate about how hard the ATO should push on collection. The Tax Ombudsman has told a parliamentary inquiry into the ATO's management of small business collectable debt that firmer collection is a "blunt instrument" and has recommended tailored enforcement that considers individual circumstances.

Anyone with a tax debt may wish to speak to a registered tax agent or contact the ATO directly.

What to watch

The ATO has not given a date for its promised process changes on remission and reasons. Watch for any published update to its remission approach or new guidance on recognising vulnerability.

The Joint Committee of Public Accounts and Audit inquiry into the ATO's management of small business collectable debt, which follows an ANAO performance audit, is ongoing. Public hearings or a report could add pressure for consistent treatment of debtors.

Parliament's final Senate sitting week of 2026 starts on 23 November, and the Mid-Year Economic and Fiscal Outlook (MYEFO) is due in mid-December. Updated budget numbers may give a fresh read on tax receipts and debt.

The Tax Ombudsman's complaint data is another barometer. Its latest annual report, for the year to 30 June 2026, recorded a record 3,668 complaints about the ATO.