Key Highlights
- According to CPA Australia's Tax News of 19 November 2026, the ATO had disallowed all of the electrician's claims for the 2024 income year.
- 18.18% of his garage electricity costs, which came to $155; and
- The reasons given were a lack of substantiation, a lack of Business use, or both.
- The tribunal's approach to the garage power bill shows how apportionment works.
In Matosin and FCT [2026] ARTA 2658, the tribunal allowed 18.18% of his garage electricity costs, or $155, and about $180 for internet and mobile. Fuel, rent and a string of other claims failed for lack of records or business use, a pointed reminder for sole traders.
What the tribunal decided
According to CPA Australia's Tax News of 19 November 2026, the ATO had disallowed all of the electrician's claims for the 2024 income year.
On review, the Administrative Review Tribunal (ART) allowed:
- 18.18% of his garage electricity costs, which came to $155; and
- about $180 for internet and mobile phone expenses.
It denied claims for:
- fuel;
- vehicle maintenance;
- rent;
- a second phone;
- financial adviser fees;
- gifts to customers; and
- a raffle donation.
The reasons given were a lack of substantiation, a lack of business use, or both. The exact decision date has not been confirmed.
Why 18.18% of a power bill
The tribunal's approach to the garage power bill shows how apportionment works. When an expense is partly private and partly for business, only the business portion is generally deductible.
The tribunal settled on 18.18% as the business share of the garage electricity. If that percentage was applied to the full garage bill, $155 implies a total of roughly $850 ($155 ÷ 0.1818 ≈ $853).
CPA Australia's summary does not explain how the tribunal arrived at 18.18%. Readers interested in the reasoning should consult the full decision.
Hypothetical example: Suppose a self-employed tradie has a $1,200 annual power bill for a home garage and can show, using a reasonable method such as a usage diary, that 15% of the electricity was used for business. The deductible amount would be $180 ($1,200 × 15%). If the tradie is on a 30% marginal tax rate, the tax saving would be $54 ($180 × 30%). Without a defensible basis for the 15% figure, the ATO or a tribunal could reduce or refuse the claim.
No records, no deduction
The broader lesson from Matosin is about evidence. Taxpayers generally bear the onus of proving that an assessment is excessive. In practice, that means showing both that an expense was incurred and that it was connected to earning assessable income.
The ART reviews the ATO's decision afresh on the evidence before it. It can affirm, vary or set aside the decision, but it cannot allow a claim the taxpayer is unable to support. Here, the tribunal allowed only what the evidence supported.
Claims for fuel and vehicle maintenance are a common example. For self-employed people, these costs often relate to a vehicle that is also used privately. Without records such as receipts, logbooks or other evidence of business use, a tribunal may have little basis to allow any portion.
Rent and a second phone raise similar issues. The taxpayer needs to show what the expense was, that it was paid, and how it related to the business.
Items such as gifts to customers and donations can face separate tests. A raffle donation, for example, may not qualify as a deductible gift, because the donor can receive a chance to win a prize in return.
How this fits with the ATO's wider approach
The decision comes as the ATO tightens record-keeping expectations in other areas.
The ATO has updated its practice statement PS LA 2001/6 on electronic device usage expenses. According to PwC's November 2026 tax update, phone and internet work expenses must now be substantiated with written evidence. A method that allowed incidental phone and internet claims of up to $50 in total with limited documentation has been removed.
The ATO's reason, per PwC, is that the new standard deduction for work-related expenses in s 25-130 of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 makes it unnecessary.
That standard deduction is enacted law. From the 2026–27 income year, a $1,000 standard deduction for work-related expenses applies, and CPA Australia says it is applied automatically to 2026–27 returns. Some items, such as union fees, professional memberships, donations and costs of managing tax affairs, remain separately claimable.
The Matosin case concerned the 2024 income year, so the standard deduction was not relevant to it. The standard deduction is also framed around work-related expenses, and it should not be assumed to replace the need for records of Business Expenses for sole traders.
What it means for sole traders
The tribunal's decision is a ruling on one taxpayer's facts. It does not change the law, but it illustrates how the existing rules are applied.
For self-employed people, the practical points from the decision are straightforward. Keep receipts and invoices. Use a reasonable, documented method to work out the business share of mixed-use costs such as home electricity, phones and vehicles. Be ready to explain how each claim connects to the business.
The electrician recovered $155 for garage power and about $180 for internet and mobile, a combined total of about $335, after having all his claims refused. The remaining items failed because the evidence was not there.
Anyone unsure about their deductions may wish to speak with a registered tax agent.
What to watch
Tribunal decisions can be appealed to the Federal Court on a question of law, within strict time limits. It is not known whether either party will appeal in Matosin.
The ATO's draft ruling TR 2026/D2, on when an individual is carrying on a business rather than a hobby or investment, closes for comment on Friday 27 November 2026. It targets side businesses, content creators and coaches.
The Tax Reform No. 4 Bill 2026, which includes dynamic PAYG instalments from 1 July 2027, remains a bill before Parliament. The final Senate sitting week of 2026 begins on 23 November.
For the 2026–27 year, the $1,000 standard deduction for work-related expenses applies automatically, and the 15% tax rate on income between $18,201 and $45,000 is scheduled to fall to 14% from 1 July 2027.






Please wait processing your request...