Key Highlights

  • The Full Federal Court dismissed the trust's appeal against the ATO's refusal to remit interest.
  • The disputed interest ran from June 2016 to December 2024.
  • Judicial review examines the legality of a decision.
  • The GIC rate for the December quarter was 11.51% a year.

Interest on an unpaid tax bill rarely makes headlines, but a Full Federal Court ruling has shown how costly it can become when the ATO refuses to waive it. A family trust has lost its appeal over interest that ran for more than eight years, from June 2016 to December 2024. With the general interest charge now at 11.51% a year and no longer tax deductible, the case is a timely reminder of how quickly an old Debt can grow.

The EMH IV Family Trust's fight over interest that ran from 2016 to 2024

The case is EMH IV Pty Ltd as Trustee for the EMH IV Family Trust v Commissioner of Taxation [2026] FCAFC 112, listed on 28 August 2026.

The trustee asked the Federal Court to review an ATO delegate's decision. The delegate had refused to remit the general interest charge (GIC) on the trust's income tax Liability for the period from 7 June 2016 to 16 December 2024.

A single judge dismissed the application in 2025, in EMH IV Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2025] FCA 1429. The trustee then appealed to the Full Court.

What the Full Court decided on lodgment dates and concessions

The appeal raised four issues.

The first was whether the primary judge was wrong to find that 16 May 2016 was the relevant date for lodging the trust's 2015 tax return.

The second was whether the trust was eligible for a concession on 5 June 2016. The third was whether the trustee was denied procedural fairness. The fourth was whether the primary judge's reasoning went beyond the proper limits of judicial review.

The Full Court rejected every ground. It held that 16 May 2016 was the correct lodgment date and that the trust was not eligible for the concession on 5 June 2016. It found no denial of procedural fairness. It also found that the primary judge had stayed within the scope of judicial review.

The appeal was dismissed with costs, so the trustee must also pay the Commissioner's legal costs.

Why judicial review is a hard road for GIC remission

The case highlights a practical point. Judicial review generally asks whether a decision was made lawfully, not whether a court would have made a different decision on the merits.

That means a taxpayer who is unhappy with a refusal to waive interest usually needs to show a legal error in how the decision was made. Disagreeing with the outcome is not enough.

Dates also matter. In this case, the court's findings about when the return was due to be lodged and whether a concession applied on a specific day were central to the result.

Not every interest dispute ends this way. In Barron and Commissioner [2026] ARTA 1330, decided on 15 July 2026, the Administrative Review Tribunal gave relief to a 76-year-old film producer on the aged pension.

He had an income tax debt of $128,580.83. An amount equal to the GIC was released on serious hardship grounds. A separate debt under a director penalty notice was not affected and remains.

The two cases are not directly comparable, because they turned on different facts and different legal pathways. Together, though, they show that outcomes depend heavily on individual circumstances and on the evidence put forward.

How quickly interest builds on an unpaid tax debt

GIC compounds daily. The rate for October to December 2026 is 11.51% a year. The rate is updated each quarter, so the cost of an old debt depends on the rates that applied in each period.

Since 1 July 2025, GIC and the shortfall interest charge are no longer tax deductible for amounts incurred on or after that date. That change is already law, and it raises the real cost of carrying a debt to the ATO.

Hypothetical example: assume a Business owner has an unpaid tax debt of $20,000 and the GIC rate stays at 11.51% a year, compounding daily, with no payments made.

After one year, the interest would be about $2,439, taking the total owed to roughly $22,439.

After three years, the interest would be about $8,247, taking the total to roughly $28,247.

Because the interest is not deductible, there is no tax saving to offset any of it. In reality the rate changes each quarter, so actual figures would differ. The example is for illustration only.

Complaints about interest are also rising. The Tax Ombudsman's latest complaints snapshot, covering April to September 2026, found that penalty and interest complaints rose from 13% to 18% of all complaints. More than three-quarters of those were about GIC. Remission or reduction happened in 5% of cases, down from 17%.

Options for taxpayers carrying ATO debt

The ATO says debts of $200,000 or less can usually be put on a payment plan online through ATO online services via myGov, or through its self-help phone line. Larger debts require a call to the ATO.

Taxpayers must call rather than use the online service in some cases. These include needing hardship help, needing more than two years to pay, or having had a firmer recovery or legal-action warning in the past six months.

People who believe interest should be remitted because of their circumstances may want to consider getting help early. A registered tax agent can explain the evidence the ATO may need and the review Options available.

What to watch and key dates

  • 31 December 2026: the current 11.51% GIC rate applies to the end of the October to December quarter, after which the ATO sets a new quarterly rate.
  • 30 June 2027: Credit cards can no longer be used to pay the ATO after this date, so payment plans linked to a credit card need to be switched.
  • Ongoing: the Tax Ombudsman's scrutiny of ATO debt collection, including its review of director penalty notices, with a report yet to be released.