Key Highlights

  • The tribunal rejected a Perth engineer's claim for about 70% of household utilities.
  • Most of the engineer's $61,286 in claimed deductions were disallowed.
  • The fixed-rate method allows an hourly claim for eligible work-from-home expenses.
  • Records are needed to link actual household costs to work use.

The Administrative Review Tribunal rejected a Perth engineer's claim that about 70% of his household Utility bills were work expenses. It disallowed most of the $61,286 in deductions he claimed. The ruling shows the type of evidence needed to establish the work-related portion of a household cost.

A $61,286 deduction claim that mostly fell over

The Administrative Review Tribunal handed down its decision on 11 February 2026, upholding the ATO's assessment.

The engineer was on a hybrid working arrangement and earned $155,747 in salary and wages. He claimed $61,286 in expenses and deductions.

The ATO audited his return in December 2023 and issued an amended assessment. He objected in March 2024, arguing his documents had not been submitted correctly. "I was not informed of any specific requirements regarding the format in which these documents needed to be provided," he wrote.

After the objection, in December 2024, the Commissioner allowed a further $129 in travel and $779 in work-related expenses. The tribunal left the rest disallowed.

Why the tribunal rejected the 70% utilities claim

The household utilities claim was $2,826, or about 70% of the bill.

The tribunal found that level excessive. The household included his spouse, two school-aged children and his elderly parents.

It said it was "reasonable to infer that the utilities were used for ordinary household purposes by multiple occupants." It found no evidentiary basis for the level of work use claimed, even though his work area was physically separate from the rest of the home.

The engineer had worked from home full-time from July to December 2022 because of personal circumstances. Part of his "other" claim related to home office renovations.

The home office claim was one part of the dispute. The amounts claimed and allowed included:

  • Car expenses: $11,130 claimed, nil allowed
  • Interest expenses: $15,407 claimed, nil allowed
  • Other work-related expenses: $17,726 claimed, $1,382 allowed at audit plus $779 on objection
  • Self-education: $4,513 claimed, nil allowed
  • Travel: $5,347 claimed, $129 allowed
  • Donations: $5,316 claimed, $68 allowed

On the car claim, the ATO said the expenses were not adequately documented, the logbook did not meet legislative requirements, and some costs had already been reimbursed by his employer.

A $140 Iranian language course was also refused. The tribunal found no evidence it maintained or improved the skills needed for his engineering role. "It is not enough that a course may generally improve some skills or knowledge," it said.

The Commissioner did not apply an additional penalty of $5,034.

The tribunal found that the engineer had not substantiated most of his deductions.

What the ATO's fixed rate method requires

Most people do not claim a share of their actual power bills. The ATO's fixed rate method instead allows a set amount per hour worked from home.

The rate was 70 cents an hour for the 2024–25 and 2025–26 income years, up from 67 cents for 2022–23 and 2023–24.

The ATO says records of actual hours worked from home are required, and estimates are not acceptable. It also requires at least one record for each type of expense covered by the rate, such as a power bill.

Hypothetical example: assume an employee works from home two days a week, eight hours a day, for 46 weeks in the 2025–26 income year, and keeps a diary of those hours.

That is 736 hours. At 70c an hour, the fixed rate claim would be $515.20.

That figure is very different from claiming a large share of the household's actual bills without evidence of work use.

How the $1,000 standard deduction changes home office claims

From the 2026–27 income year, a new $1,000 standard deduction for work-related expenses applies. This is already law, and it applies automatically to eligible residents with labour income such as salary and wages.

Working from home costs are among the "covered expenses" that reduce the standard deduction dollar for dollar.

If the fixed-rate claim were $515.20 in 2026–27, the standard deduction would fall to $484.80. The combined deduction for covered expenses in that example would be $1,000.

If covered expenses add up to more than $1,000, the standard deduction falls to nil and the larger claim is made instead. In that case the usual record-keeping rules still apply to the amounts claimed.

The ATO also says that from 1 July 2026 the $300 substantiation threshold and the $150 laundry limit no longer apply.

Union fees and professional association memberships are not covered expenses. They are still claimed separately.

The ATO has also updated its practice statement on home office and device expenses. Phone and internet work expenses must be backed by written evidence, and the old "up to $50" shortcut for small claims has been removed.

What to watch and key dates

  • 2026–27 income year: the ATO is yet to publish a fixed rate for work-from-home expenses, and the $1,000 standard deduction applies for the first time.
  • Ongoing: further tribunal decisions on work-related deductions, which regularly turn on records, logbooks and evidence of actual work use.