Highlights
- Trustees must report Assets at Market Value when preparing the fund’s accounts and retain evidence supporting the figures.
- Recent comparable sales and independent valuations can help establish the market value of a fund’s direct property holdings.
- Financial statements and other objective records can support values for unlisted investments without a readily observable market price.
- Reported values can affect member balances and the figures used to assess Division 296 tax on large super balances.
Listed investments come with observable prices. Real estate, private loans and unlisted holdings can require more work, which is why the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has put evidence for hard-to-value self-managed super fund (SMSF) assets in focus.
The market value requirement
Under regulation 8.02B of the Superannuation regulations, trustees must value SMSF assets at market value when preparing the fund's accounts each year. This is not a one-off exercise; it is an annual requirement that applies to every asset the fund holds, from listed shares to direct property, unlisted investments and collectables.
Why valuations draw scrutiny
Market valuation reviews sit at the top of the ATO's SMSF auditor compliance focus for 2026–27. The regulator wants to confirm that auditors obtained adequate objective evidence supporting each reported value. This focus is sharpened by Division 296, the new tax on Earnings relating to large super balances, which applies from 1 July 2026 and relies on accurate total super balance figures. Valuations that are soft or poorly documented could distort a member's Division 296 position.
Evidence for different asset classes
The assets most likely to attract questions are those without a readily observable market price: direct real property, unlisted companies and unit trusts, private loans, and collectables such as art. For these, a trustee's own estimate is rarely enough. The ATO expects objective and contemporaneous support, which might mean an independent valuation, recent comparable sales, a rates notice combined with market evidence, or reliable financial statements for an unlisted entity. The evidence should be recent enough to reflect the position at the fund's year-end.
Listed investments are more straightforward because market prices are readily available, but even here the reported figures must reconcile to holding statements and to the fund's accounts. Consistency across the accounts, the audit and the annual return is part of what makes a valuation defensible.
The effect on Division 296
Valuations now carry a direct tax consequence. Because Division 296 relies on total super balance figures, a soft valuation is no longer just a presentation issue; it can change how much tax a member pays on earnings relating to balances above AUD 3 million, and above AUD 10 million. That is why the ATO has put market valuation reviews at the top of its auditor compliance program for 2026–27 and specifically linked them to audits involving Division 296 assets. The practical response for trustees is to build a valuation file for each asset every year, so that when an auditor, or the ATO, asks how a value was determined, the answer is documented and supportable rather than reconstructed after the fact.






Please wait processing your request...