Key Highlights
- An SMSF can Lease qualifying Business real property to a related party.
- Advance rent and discounts can draw auditor scrutiny.
- Independent appraisals can help establish what is commercially reasonable.
- Written lease terms and rent collection records help substantiate the arrangement.
Leasing business real property to a related business is one of the more common SMSF strategies, and the law expressly allows it. But a case discussed by SMSF audit specialists this week shows that unusual lease terms can raise questions that trustees need to be ready to answer with evidence.
The case under discussion
At an Auditors Institute webinar, presenters examined an SMSF lease to a related party in which the commercial tenant paid nine months' rent worth $450,000 upfront.
Auditors Institute ambassador Graeme Colley questioned whether the arrangement reflected arm's-length terms and what the prepayment could mean for tax. He asked what commercial reason a related tenant had for paying to secure the lease.
David Burrows, an Auditors Institute director and managing director of Assurify, said rent can be prepaid for commercial or tax reasons. He said a Trustee needs evidence showing why the prepayment and any related discount reflect terms independent parties would accept.
What the rules require
The ATO's guidance on Investment restrictions explains that, generally, an SMSF must not acquire Assets from related parties, lend to them or give them financial assistance. Business real property is an important exception: it can be acquired from a related party at Market Value and leased to a related party without being counted as an in-house asset.
The exception does not remove the need for commerciality. The ATO's investment strategy guidance states that SMSF investments must be made on a commercial, arm's-length basis that reflects true market value. Its investment restrictions page also notes that non-arm's length income may be taxed at the highest marginal rate.
Related parties are defined broadly. They include members, their relatives, business partners and entities they control or influence, as well as standard employer-sponsors.
Why upfront or unusual terms attract attention
Upfront rent, discounts, rent-free periods or terms that look tailored to the relationship between the fund and the tenant are not automatically prohibited. The issue is whether an unrelated landlord and tenant would plausibly agree to the same terms. If they would not, the fund may face questions about arm's-length dealing and tax consequences, and the auditor may need to consider whether reporting obligations arise.
The ATO's 2026–27 auditor compliance focus also emphasises sufficient and appropriate audit evidence. That suggests auditors are likely to keep pressing for documentation where related-party dealings look out of the ordinary.
Practical considerations for trustees
Obtain independent market evidence. A rental appraisal from a qualified, independent valuer or agent helps demonstrate that rent and terms reflect the market.
Document the commercial reason. If rent is prepaid or a discount is offered, record why, what alternatives were considered and how the terms compare with market practice.
Use a written lease. A formal lease with market terms, rent reviews and default provisions is far easier to defend than an informal arrangement.
Enforce the lease. Collecting rent on time and acting on arrears is part of showing the arrangement is commercial.
Talk to the auditor early. Raising an unusual arrangement before year end gives trustees time to gather evidence.
Hypothetical example
Consider a hypothetical fund that owns a Warehouse leased to the members' trading company. The company offers to prepay a year's rent in exchange for a 10% discount. Before agreeing, the trustees obtain an agent's written opinion on whether comparable landlords offer such discounts and keep it with the minutes. If the evidence does not support the discount, they may decide not to proceed.
The takeaway
Related-party leases of business real property are permitted, but the onus sits with trustees to show the terms are commercial. Where a lease looks unusual, trustees should expect their auditor to ask for evidence, and should have it ready.


_11_18_2026_06_31_04_094299.jpg)



Please wait processing your request...