Highlights
- The High Court held in Hill v Zuda that regulation 6.17A does not apply to SMSFs.
- The trust deed and governing rules decide whether an SMSF binding nomination is valid and how long it lasts.
- A deed silent on lapsing nominations leaves families and executors open to disputes over validity.
- Trustees have six months to restructure after a member dies and must notify the ATO within 28 days.
Many members believe a binding death benefit nomination works the same way in every super fund. It does not. Inside an SMSF, whether a nomination binds, how long it lasts and who acts for a deceased member can turn on a few lines in a document written years ago. A silent or outdated deed can leave families arguing at the worst possible time.
The deed that says nothing about lapsing
Picture a fund whose deed was last varied in 2008. Its nomination clauses never say whether a binding nomination lapses or continues indefinitely. The Trustee has made lapsing nominations before and now wants a non-lapsing one.
Non-lapsing nominations were not a common concept in 2008, so a deed of that age probably does not clearly allow one. The sensible steps are to ask the deed provider and get confirmation in writing, take legal advice if doubt remains, and amend the deed so it states whether nominations can be lapsing or non-lapsing and how they are made, renewed and revoked.
Why the deed beats the regulations
The key case is Hill v Zuda Pty Ltd [2022] HCA 21, decided on 15 June 2022. A deceased member's daughter argued his binding nomination failed because it did not comply with regulation 6.17A of the SIS Regulations, which among other things says a nomination lasts three years unless renewed or revoked.
The High Court unanimously dismissed the appeal. Regulation 6.17A, properly construed, does not apply to an SMSF, because the relevant parts were made for section 59(1A) of the SIS Act, which does not apply to SMSFs. The validity of binding nominations in an SMSF is governed by the trust deed and the fund's governing rules.
That flexibility cuts both ways. A well-drafted deed can allow non-lapsing nominations with clear formalities. A vague one invites argument.
Who acts for a deceased member
Deeds also shape who controls the fund after a death. The requirement that all members be trustees, and all trustees members, is not automatically met when a member dies or loses capacity. A fund does not become non-complying if the member's legal personal representative is appointed in their place and the transition happens within six months.
The ATO likewise allows six months to restructure after a death, and trustees must notify it within 28 days of a change in trustee structure. It is not always simple: the representative may be unclear, unwilling, unsuitable or may have renounced. Where a father and daughter are trustees and the father is the only member, the outcome depends on the deed, and if the daughter remains both executor and trustee, further action may not be needed to stay compliant.
What the ATO expects
The fund's trust deed must be followed, even if it differs from the member's will. Without a binding nomination, the remaining trustees decide how benefits are distributed under the deed and super laws, and benefits should be paid as soon as possible after death.
Only a dependant, a nominated beneficiary or the deceased's legal personal representative can receive a death benefit. Dependants include a spouse or former spouse, certain children and a person in an interdependency relationship. A benefit for a non-dependant must be paid as a lump sum, in no more than two amounts.
Questions to put to your deed
Trustees may wish to check:
- Does it permit binding nominations, and does it say whether they lapse?
- What formalities apply, such as witnesses, form and delivery to the trustee?
- Who becomes trustee, or director of the corporate trustee, on death or loss of capacity?
- How does it treat reversionary pensions alongside nominations?
Sam made a binding nomination in 2015 under a deed silent on lapsing. If a relative argues it expired after three years, the outcome turns on the deed's wording, not on regulation 6.17A.
The bottom line
Since Hill v Zuda, the deed is the main rulebook for nominations and for who can step in. Older deeds are worth putting in front of a lawyer with SMSF experience.






Please wait processing your request...