Highlights

  • Use consistent periods and calculation methods when comparing funds.
  • Check whether the figures include reinvested distributions and which fees are deducted.
  • Remember that the annualised rate smooths changes made along the way.
  • Use the worked figures to separate the main effect from other changes.

A chart shows one fund’s three-year gain alongside another fund’s annual result. The percentages need a common time basis. The figures give you a way to trace what changed and how it affects the holding.

What the figures measure

Identify the starting value and the period that applies before reading the result. A report can measure the fund alone, the change in a particular unit price or the outcome after distributions. The description next to the figure tells you what has already been included. Write those conventions down along with the dates, especially where one source rounds its results or reports in a different currency. Use consistent periods and calculation methods when comparing funds.

How to put returns on the same basis

A cumulative 33.1% gain over three years equals 10% a year compounded, since 1.10 multiplied three times is 1.331. A 20% gain, a 10% gain and then a flat year produce a cumulative gain of 32% because the second gain applies to the value after the first. Annualising compresses a path like that into one rate. The original sequence remains visible in the annual figures.

In a worked comparison, keep the holdings constant unless a trade or cash movement is part of the example. That isolates the effect being measured. Use percentage points for differences between percentages and an opening balance for converting a rate to dollars. For outcomes spanning several periods, the value carried forward affects what a later percentage change means in dollars.

Percentage figures are easier to interpret when you can state what would happen to a common starting amount. Convert the rates to dollars using that amount and record the results in parallel. If the report gives a relative difference, check whether it uses percentage points or expresses one figure as a percentage of another. Those two calculations give distinct answers and can look deceptively similar on a page.

What can change the comparison

Check whether the figures include reinvested distributions and which fees are deducted. Remember that the annualised rate smooths changes made along the way.

Extend the exercise by changing one input. Depending on the measure, that might be the starting exposure, the market movement or the amount of cash taken out. Recalculate with the other assumptions held steady. If the values come from separate reports, press the comparison one step further by checking treatment of fees, cash distributions and the dates used for both figures.

In a longer comparison, keep the intermediate results. A single end figure can conceal a fall, a recovery or a shift in the weights of the underlying assets. If the calculation describes sensitivity to just one change, hold the other drivers steady in the example. The reported outcome may include several effects moving at once, and the individual calculation explains only the part that was modelled.