Highlights

  • The Full Federal Court found that profitability is not essential to commercial parking status.
  • The High Court refused special leave on 8 October 2026.
  • Employers may need to reassess the status of nearby public parking facilities.
  • ATO ruling TR 2021/2 explains conditions for car parking fringe benefits.

Employers offering staff parking may need to revisit how nearby public parking facilities are classified for Fringe Benefits tax (FBT). The Full Federal Court’s 2026 decision in the Toowoomba Regional Council dispute concluded that a parking station need not be operated for profit to qualify as commercial. The High Court refused special leave to appeal on 8 October 2026, leaving the appellate decision in place.

What the Courts Decided

In Commissioner of Taxation v Toowoomba Regional Council [2026] FCAFC 50, the Full Federal Court considered whether the meaning of a commercial parking station required the Facility to operate profitably, or be intended to do so. The court rejected that limitation and allowed the Commissioner’s appeal.

A refusal of special leave is not the same as a separate High Court judgment on every issue in the case. It means the proposed appeal was not heard, while the Full Federal Court decision remains the relevant appellate ruling. The decision may nevertheless change assessments where employers previously assumed non-profit facilities were excluded.

How a Parking Benefit Can Arise

ATO Taxation Ruling TR 2021/2 explains the conditions under which an employer provides a car parking fringe benefit. These include an employee parking at or near the primary workplace for relevant periods, and a qualifying commercial parking station within the statutory distance whose all-day fee exceeds the applicable threshold. Other conditions and exemptions also need to be satisfied.

The commercial status of a parking facility is therefore only one element. A car park charging fees does not automatically make all nearby employer-provided parking taxable. Employers still need to consider the employee’s use of the space, location, applicable threshold, valuation approach and any relevant small-business or other exemption.

Why the Toowoomba Facts Matter

The underlying dispute concerned parking at Toowoomba’s Grand Central Shopping Centre. ATO legal materials record that the centre offered periods of free parking alongside longer-stay fees, including reduced pricing for particular users. The original Federal Court decision had favoured the council before the Commissioner succeeded on appeal.

The question was whether a facility available to the public in a commercial setting could fall within the statutory definition without a profit-making intention. That issue can arise beyond shopping centres, especially where parking is provided as part of a wider Business or public service. Every car park must still be assessed against the requirements of the legislation and current guidance.

Practical Review for Employers

Employers can review which facilities operate within the relevant radius of each workplace, the lowest qualifying all-day charges and the arrangements under which their own parking spaces are provided. Record-keeping is important because daily use and fee evidence affect calculation and compliance.

A business that previously excluded a nearby facility solely because it did not aim to make a profit should reconsider that reasoning. However, no employer should assume the court ruling proves an FBT Liability without checking all conditions. The next FBT year starts on 1 April 2027, providing a clear point to assess parking policies and valuation methods.

Key Insights

The High Court refusal leaves in place a Full Federal Court ruling that profit intention is not necessary for commercial parking status under FBT law. This broadens the practical facilities employers may need to review, but it does not remove the other statutory conditions or exemptions. Accurate location, pricing and employee-use records remain central to assessing any liability.